There is no rush to buy lithium stock Pilbara Minerals

Having successfully traded Pilbara Minerals (ASX:PLS) shares previously, we recently researched the Company following the release of results for the 12 months to 30 June 2022 (FY22). Since our report in The Dynamic Investor on 30 August, the shares have continued to outperform. In this note, we discuss some of the key short-to-medium catalysts that make PLS an attractive stock – but at current levels, is there scope for further upside or is it time for a breather?

About Pilbara Minerals

Pilbara Minerals operates the Pilgangoora spodumene* project (100% owned by PLS) in the Pilbara region of Western Australia. The Pilgangoora ore body is one of the largest hard rock lithium deposits in the world. It is considered strategically important within the global lithium supply chain. The Pilgangoora Project’s spodumene concentrates meet the metallurgical specifications of the entire range of lithium products. The project is one of the few hard rock lithium production operations globally that has both the resource size and existing operating platform to enable a rapid scale-up of production to meet long-term requirements. The first production from the Pilgangoora project occurred in September 2018.

The operation consists of two processing plants: i) The Pilgan Plant, located on the northern side of the Pilgangoora area, which produces a spodumene concentrate and a tantalite concentrate, and ii) The Ngungaju Plant, which is located immediately adjacent to the Pilgangoora project to the south and produces a spodumene concentrate. This project was acquired in January 2021 from Altura Lithium Operations P/L.

* Spodumene is a lithium aluminium silicate mineral usually found in pegmatite veins. In its natural opaque form, Spodumene is worked as a lithium ore and processed into different grades for use in ceramics, glass, batteries, steel, fluxing agents and medicine.

Key Fundamental Drivers

Substantial Increase in Production Planned

The Company has a pathway to producing 1Mtpa of spodumene concentrate through organic expansion. In late June 2022, the board made a Final Investment Decision (FID) to proceed with the P680 project. This will see an increase in the nameplate production capacity of the Pilgan plant from 580-680Ktpa of spodumene concentrate.

Production from the P680 project will support the chemical conversion facility currently under development in South Korea under a joint venture with POSCO.

The next phased expansion – the P1000 project – is subject to a separate FID (targeted for late December 2022) and is expected to lift production to 1Mtpa.

Production for FY23 is expected to be 540-580Ktpa. This is higher than expected, given the faster ramp-up of Ngungaju. The plant reached its daily nameplate throughput run-rate capacity in June 2022. The Company expects to achieve 180-200,000ktpa concentrate production rate in the 1Q23.

Pricing Environment Remains Highly Favourable

Up until mid-2021, the Company had typically sold its spodumene concentrate under offtake contracts. In order to capitalise on the surging spot prices, PLS recently established the Battery Metals Exchange (BMX). The BMX is a digital trading platform for battery raw materials and enables auctions to be undertaken. The aim behind the digital sales platform is to create a transparent marketing mechanism where converters (i.e. purchasers of spodumene concentrate) can access material without offtake or price negotiations.

The digital platform will also allow PLS to begin pricing intermediate products and potentially a forward pricing mechanism. This would greatly reduce risks around its future ramp-up profile.

The first online auction of spodumene concentrate was undertaken in late July 2021. Each subsequent auction has resulted in higher realised prices and since commencement, the BMX has shown to be an excellent indicator of real time price trends. In early August 2022, PLS completed its 8th auction on the BMX platform. The result from the auction was strong, with the realised price of US$6,350/dmt being 3% higher than the previous BMX auction price of US$6,188/dmt and matched the price record achieved during the pre-auction sale on 23 June 2022.

Stronger Cash Levels Bring Capital Management into Play

As at 30 June 2022, PLS held a net cash balance of $265m and excludes the $282m letters of credit. With the Company now comfortably profitable and with a strengthening balance sheet, capital management options beyond the capital expenditure on P1000 appear focused on dividends. However, other options remain (such as additional acquisitions) cannot be ruled out.

As expected, the Company did not declare a final dividend, as PLS indicated that loan covenants at Pilgangoora were likely to roll off December and dividends were more likely to come once the franking credit balance is built in (most likely in 2H23). Having said that, the strong cash position means that the potential to commence dividend payments remains a possibility in FY23.

Fundamental View

Coupled with strong underlying fundamentals, we see several positive catalysts for PLS over the short-to-medium term. These include:

i. Further spot sales of spodumene concentrate at higher prices on the Company’s BMX platform present a key near-term catalyst for PLS. They are underpinned by the continuing strong outlook for the lithium market, where the increasing demand/supply gap is pushing up spodumene prices.
ii. Spodumene production is forecast to rise more than 50% in FY23. Combined with higher prices, this should see PLS report a near-threefold increase in earnings and cash flow generation, which are both expected to overshadow any increase in unit costs beyond the guided range.
iii. The potential for higher Ngungaju production unlocked by improved recovery.
iv. PLS remains an attractive takeover target, given the strategic location of its asset base, a price leadership position via the BMX platform and a more open share register.

Charting View

Our previous charting comment on PLS in The Dynamic Investor was on 26 July when it was trading at $2.54 where we noted that it was a buying opportunity. Since mid-August, however, the daily ranges have expanded which is a warning sign that the recent run is ending. We also have the shares rejecting near the April peak, and there is also some bearish divergence with the daily RSI. All of this means that PLS is likely to come back in the short-term and traders can wait for cheaper levels. The next support level down is $3. If that cannot hold, then we would be targeting levels near $2.60.

Pilbara Minerals (ASX:PLS) daily chart
Pilbara Minerals (ASX:PLS) daily chart


Michael Gable is managing director of Fairmont Equities.


Current share prices available here.

You can learn more about technical analysis in this article.

 An 8-week FREE TRIAL to The Dynamic Investor can be found HERE.

Would you like us to call you when we have a great idea? Check out our services.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general advice only. Read our full disclaimer HERE.

Like this article? Share it now on Facebook and Twitter!