Is now the time to buy Premier Investments?

We recently researched Premier Investments (ASX:PMV) to assess progress under a new simplified strategy. Recent share price strength suggests growing investor confidence in a successful Smiggle turnaround. The market is seemingly pricing in a recovery in sales growth that has so far failed to materialise. Against this backdrop, we assess the likely success of the Smiggle strategy, as well as the uncertainties and challenges facing the Peter Alexander brand. Is there further share price upside, or is the risk-reward becoming increasingly unfavourable at current levels?

About Premier Investments

Premier Investments (PMV) owns global retail brands Smiggle and Peter Alexander.

  • Smiggle is a retailer selling bags & accessories, pencil cases, food & drink, stationery, toys and school supplies. Smiggle has a network of 268 stores (including concessions) in major developed countries/regions, including Australia & NZ, UK & Ireland and Asia (Singapore, Hong Kong & Malaysia).
  • Peter Alexander is a retailer selling sleepwear (men, women & children), homeware and beauty products. Peter Alexander has a network of 125 stores across Australia and 16 in NZ, having recently exited its UK operations.

In early 2025, the Company successfully completed the sale of five core apparel brands in Australia & NZ to Myer, therefore ceasing to own the apparel brands (comprising the brands Just Jeans, Jay Jays, Jacqui E, Portmans and Dotti) and its investment in Myer. The Company also holds a 25.5% stake in small kitchen electrical appliance wholesaler Breville Group (ASX: BRG), as well as an investment in real property assets.

Smiggle – Can the Strategy Reset Improve Performance?

In March 2026, PMV reset its strategic shift for Smiggle, centred on reclaiming Smiggle’s core 6–12-year-old customer market. Despite progress in implementing the strategic reset, Smiggle’s sales for the 52 weeks to 25 July 2026 (FY26) were down -12.9%. The result was materially worse than the -10.7% decline recorded in 1H26. This highlights the ongoing challenges facing the brand and indicates that the benefits of the reset have yet to translate into improved trading performance.

Sales growth for Smiggle in FY27 is expected to remain weak, as the refreshed product range and marketing initiatives take time to gain traction. However, the strategic reset is expected to drive a recovery in several ways: i) Product repositioning (innovation, category expansion, licensing); ii) Brand elevation (marketing reset, customer engagement); iii) Investment across stores, digital and wholesale channels and iv) Improved traction from the new loyalty program.

The key test is whether the refreshed product range and marketing can restore sales growth and improve profitability without requiring excessive store investment. To this end, closing inventory declined -8.9% to $96.7m despite Peter Alexander’s store expansion, leaving both brands with clean inventory entering the critical 1H27 peak trading period. This reduces clearance risk following Smiggle’s transition period and should provide a cleaner test of the refreshed product range.

Uniquely combining both Fundamental and Technical Analysis

Not yet a subscriber? Join now for FREE!

Receive our weekly tips and strategies into your inbox each week.

BONUS: Sign up now to download our 21 page Trading Guide.

Peter Alexander – Uncertainties & Challenges

  • Sales Pressure from Discounting & Consumers Trading Down: Peter Alexander is exposed to consumer downtrading given its premium price positioning. In particular, cheaper alternatives such as Kmart (where comparable products are priced at approximately 3.6x less) pose a competitive threat.
  • Uncertainty on Concessions Strategy: Peter Alexander returns to Myer across 24 concession stores from August 2027. This presents both margin opportunities through lower operating costs and risks from weakening department store sales, consumer downtrading and potential gross margin dilution.
  • Potential Implications from David Jones’ Difficulties: David Jones’ financial difficulties could increase promotional pressure on Myer and Peter Alexander’s margins. However, potential store closures may allow Myer to capture additional customer traffic and market share.
  • International Expansion Still on the Agenda: Despite exiting its three UK stores due to challenging trading conditions, PMV remains committed to Peter Alexander’s international growth. Expansion is likely to be through wholesale opportunities and potential overseas store rollouts, supported by its strong cash position.

Balance Sheet Remains in Net Cash Position

PMV held a net cash balance of $322.4m as at 25 July 2026. The balance sheet supports opportunity for a regular return of capital to shareholders (in addition to the ongoing share buyback), store investment and potential retail Merger & Acquisition (M&A) opportunities. Regarding M&A, the Company noted at the FY26 results release that “the current challenging retail environment may present new opportunities”.

The balance sheet is further strengthened by the Company’s 25.2% stake in BRG, with the investment valued at $1.08b as at 25 July 2026 ($1.20b at the time of writing).

Fundamental View

While PMV shares are currently trading at a discount of ~10% to its market valuation, we take a cautious view on the shares for two reasons:

Firstly, a weaker consumer backdrop (i.e. higher inflation & two consecutive RBA cash rate increases) has increased the risk of another profit downgrade/further downward revisions to consensus earnings estimates over the course of 1H27.

Secondly, it is still too early to gauge the success, or otherwise, of Smiggle’s product performance under the new strategy. While the initial implementation has progressed in line with management’s plan, investors should remain cautious given the brand’s recent underperformance and the gap between previous growth ambitions and actual performance. In particular, Smiggle’s historical international expansion opportunities and sales growth expectations have not always translated into the anticipated outcomes.

The new strategy will therefore need to demonstrate sustained improvements in customer engagement, sales productivity and profitability in order to justify a re-rating of PMV shares. To this end, we note that any underperformance for Smiggle under the new strategy (i.e. the turnaround takes longer than anticipated or financial targets aren’t met) presents a downside risk to consensus estimates for group EPS growth of +9% over FY26-29 on a CAGR basis, which we contend factors in a degree of success with the new Smiggle strategy.

A key risk to our view is M&A activity, given the strong net cash balance sheet position.

Charting View

PMV spent most of 2025 trending lower but it has then essentially traded sideways during this year. However, we can see that although the stock has been making lower lows since January, the weekly RSI has been trending higher in that time. This divergence between the two is a bullish sign, so PMV is therefore a chart worth keeping an eye on. If it can break above the June peak near $15, then we can start to be confident that a low is in place and that should lead to much higher levels. Short-term, however, it is looking a little overbought and we could see weakness back towards $13.

Premier Investments (ASX:PMV) weekly chart
Premier Investments (ASX:PMV) weekly chart

 

Michael Gable is managing director of Fairmont Equities.

 

CLICK HERE to read our Testimonials.

Current share prices available here.

You can learn more about technical analysis in this article.

 An 8-week FREE TRIAL to The Dynamic Investor can be found HERE.

Would you like us to call you when we have a recommendation? Check out our services.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general advice only. Read our full disclaimer HERE.

Like this article? Share it now on Facebook and X!